Glass Lake Preservation Corporation
Meeting Minutes
Date: Saturday, October 24, 2026
Time: 10:00 AM – 11:42 AM
Location: Sand Lake Town Hall
1. Attendance
Board Members Present
- Bob Happy, President
- Tim Komdat
- Valerie Lang Waldin, Secretary
- Carolyn Windover, Treasurer
Board Members Absent
- Maureen Straight
- John Windover
Guest Speaker: Stephen Clemens, Town of Sand Lake Supervisor
2. Call to Order
President Bob Happy called the meeting to order at 10:06 AM. The Pledge of Allegiance was recited.
3. Executive Summary
The primary focus of the meeting was the condition of the Glass Lake dam and road crossing, regulatory compliance with the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), and the long-term financial sustainability of the Glass Lake Preservation Corporation (GLPC) and the GLPC’s ability to fund maintenance of the dam.
Town Supervisor Stephen Clemens explained that the Town is pursuing a safe, temporary reopening of the road under restricted traffic conditions while evaluating a longer-term bridge replacement project. Required engineering documentation and DEC approvals remain critical to moving forward.
The Treasurer reported that recent engineering and lake-treatment expenses have significantly depleted GLPC funds. Members discussed increasing participation in dues payments, organizing fundraising and outreach efforts, improving payment methods, and exploring a potential special tax district to provide sustainable funding.
The meeting also addressed the need for additional volunteers, committee formation, communications improvements, the Creek Lane dock issue, lake lowering, Board of Directors’ terms, and future approval of revised bylaws.
4. Key Discussion Points
A. Glass Lake Dam and Road Crossing
Supervisor Clemens provided an update on the Town’s assessment and plans for the road crossing over the dam.
Current condition and temporary stabilization
- The Town engineer evaluated the crossing and raised concerns about the structural integrity of the road and underlying dam system.
- The road was closed as a precaution.
- A preliminary stabilization plan involves installing rock-filled metal baskets and reinforcing the deteriorated west bank.
- The estimated cost of physical stabilization was discussed as approximately $30,000–$50,000, subject to permitting, engineering requirements, and final construction costs.
- DEC permits are required for work within the streambed. The Town indicated that these permits cannot be obtained until the required Engineering Assessment (EA) and Emergency Action Plan (EAP) are filed and approved by DEC.
Temporary reopening
- The Town is planning on reopening the crossing to one lane with reduced traffic capacity.
- The proposed temporary plan includes speed bumps, signage, a reduced weight limit, and shifting traffic away from the edge of the dam toward the lakeside.
- A preliminary weight limit in the range of 5–7 tons was discussed; the final limit will be determined by the Town engineer.
- The Town will determine whether additional stabilization is warranted to restore greater road capacity after the required approvals are obtained.
Long-term bridge replacement
- The Town intends to pursue funding through the Culvert New York program, which Supervisor Clemens stated may provide up to $500,000 for replacement.
- The proposed design would move the bridge abutments back so the bridge spans over the dam without placing its structural load on the dam.
- The Town anticipated applying in February 2027, with funding decisions expected around November 2027.
- If approved on the first application round, engineering and construction could occur in approximately 2029–2030.
- The Town will weigh the cost of temporary stabilization against the timing and likelihood of permanent replacement.
Coordination and regulatory compliance
- Glass Lake is classified as a Class B dam, described during the meeting as an intermediate-hazard classification.
- The EA and EAP are key regulatory documents. The engineering assessment and emergency planning documentation must meet DEC requirements.
- Supervisor Clemens emphasized that failure to achieve compliance could lead to enforcement action, an order of consent, additional expenses, and ongoing reporting requirements.
- The GLPC is working with its engineer to update the required documentation.
- The parties discussed revisiting a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the Town and GLPC to clarify cooperation, responsibilities, and the financial framework for future work.
- Questions regarding property ownership, title, dam responsibility, and liability remain unresolved and if pursued will require additional research. Presently the status is such that the Town of Sand Lake owns the road over the dam, and the Glass Lake Preservation Corporation owns the bottom of Glass Lake and the dam.
B. Financial Condition and Treasurer’s Report
Treasurer Carolyn Windover reported that recent expenses have significantly reduced the corporation’s available funds.
Key points:
- Lake treatment and engineering expenses have placed substantial pressure on GLPC finances.
- The engineering report cost $27,750.
- The Treasurer reported that approximately $1,000 remained in the account after recent dues receipts and payment of the engineering report.
- An additional engineering-related bill of approximately $11,500 was mentioned by the President as outstanding; its status and payment arrangements require follow-up.
- Fewer than half of the approximately 77 lake properties are currently contributing dues.
- Members agreed that the existing voluntary-dues model does not adequately support future engineering, dam maintenance, lake treatment, and regulatory obligations.
- The current $250 contribution level was discussed as insufficient to meet long-term financial needs.
Members discussed several possible approaches:
- Increasing annual dues.
- Offering monthly or quarterly payment options.
- Providing easier online payment and automatic-payment options.
- Sending a new request for contributions, including a proposed $250 donation request.
- Developing a long-term operating and capital budget.
- Changing corporate status from a 501c4 to a 501c3 for grant eligibility.
- Exploring a special tax district to distribute eligible costs more broadly among properties.
No final decision was made on a dues increase, a 501c3 designation or the establishment of a special tax district.
C. Potential Special Tax District
Supervisor Clemens explained how a special tax district could provide a more predictable funding mechanism for dam compliance and lake-related expenses.
Discussion included:
- Funding could be allocated according to assessed property values, subject to applicable requirements.
- The Town could administer collections, with funds designated for the district’s authorized purposes.
- The process may involve a Town Board resolution subject to permissive referendum or a petition process.
- A formal map plan and supporting documentation would be required.
- A district could potentially support future engineering assessments, dam maintenance, and other approved lake-related expenses.
- The Town’s ability to contribute would require further review of the applicable legal and financial requirements.
- Members discussed preparing a financial proposal showing projected annual needs and the potential cost to property owners.
The Board and volunteers will need to evaluate the legal requirements, expected costs, and level of community support before deciding whether to pursue this option.
D. Fundraising, Outreach, and Membership Participation
Members emphasized the need to increase participation and improve communication with lake residents.
Proposals included:
- Sending a letter requesting contributions, with $250 discussed as a proposed amount.
- Organizing door-to-door outreach to explain the corporation’s financial position and encourage participation.
- Providing clearer information about how funds are used and why future funding is needed.
- Preparing financial projections to support discussions about dues or a potential tax district.
- Establishing a finance/fundraising committee.
Will Cobb offered to assist with analysis of property assessments and potential tax-district costs. Carolyn Windover requested assistance with financial projections and improved dues collection.
E. Committees and Board Support
The Secretary noted that the corporation needs additional volunteer support and an active Vice President.
The following committee needs were identified:
- Dam Committee
- Communications Committee
- Finance/Fundraising Committee
- Bylaws Committee
Members were encouraged to volunteer as committee chairs or members. No formal committee appointments were recorded.
The Board was reported to have six members, with one opening on the seven-member Board. The Board also agreed to review its records and communicate board-member names and term dates to the membership.
F. Communications and Membership Updates
Members discussed improving communications so residents receive timely updates even when no immediate resolution is available.
Proposed improvements included:
- Establishing a communications committee.
- Updating the membership email list.
- Creating a group distribution list or similar system.
- Continue using blind-copy email distribution to protect members’ email addresses while creating a Google email list for simple group communication and interaction.
- Providing periodic updates on dam work, finances, fundraising, and other ongoing projects.
- Coordinating communications with door-to-door outreach.
Valerie Lang Waldin agreed to work on the email distribution system, with Will Cobb offering assistance. Valerie will also follow up with Cyndie Mitchell and Mary Beckmann regarding communications committee participation.
G. Creek Lane Dock
President Bob Happy reported that a new dock had been installed on GLPC property at Creek Lane.
- Existing docks were described as grandfathered under a prescriptive easement.
- The newly installed dock was not considered covered by that arrangement.
- Following consultation with GLPC attorney Lawrence Howard, the proposed next step is to write to the property owner requesting removal of the new dock.
H. Lake Lowering
The corporation discussed the unsuccessful lake-lowering effort during the current year. Although the valve was opened, there was no perceptible reduction in lake level.
The next lake-lowering effort is planned for October 2, 2027.
I. Bylaws
The Board previously met to review the bylaws, and the revised materials were distributed.
No action was required at this meeting. The membership will be asked to vote on affirming the revised bylaws before the next meeting.
J. Additional Engineering Considerations
Al Aita raised concerns that prior engineering analysis may not have fully incorporated an updated report and hydraulic-flow analysis relating to the spillway.
He indicated that additional engineering review could cost approximately $15,000. The matter was raised for future consideration; no decision was made to authorize this work.
Questions concerning the history of the dam, property ownership, and deed/title documentation were also raised. These matters remain open for further investigation.
5. Motions and Approvals
- Approval of June 20, 2026 Meeting Minutes
- Motion: Valerie Lang Waldin
- Second: Tim Komdat
- Result: Approved.
- Approval of Treasurer’s Report
- Motion: Valerie Lang Waldin
- Second: Nancy Dunn
- Result: Motion carried.
- Adjournment
- Motion: Al Aita
- Second: Nancy Dunn
- Result: Motion carried.
- The meeting concluded at 11:42 AM.
No formal vote was recorded on a special tax district, dues increase, committee appointments, 501c3 status or permanent bridge replacement.
6. Action Items
| # | Action Item | Responsible Party | Timing / Status |
| 1 | Complete the required Engineering Assessment and Emergency Action Plan updates and coordinate filing and approval with DEC. | GLPC; Valerie Lang Waldin as DEC contact; GLPC engineer | In progress; priority |
| 2 | Obtain DEC approvals and permits required for stabilization work within the streambed. | Town of Sand Lake, coordinated with GLPC | Dependent on Item 1 |
| 3 | Obtain the engineer’s final recommended temporary traffic and vehicle weight limits for a possible one-lane reopening. | Town of Sand Lake and Town engineer | Pending required engineering review |
| 4 | Evaluate temporary stabilization costs against the schedule and prospects for permanent bridge replacement. | Town of Sand Lake | Following engineering and permitting updates |
| 5 | Prepare and submit an application to the Culvert New York program for bridge replacement funding. | Town of Sand Lake | Target: February 2027 |
| 6 | Revisit the MOU to clarify cooperation, responsibilities, and the financial framework for future dam and road work. | GLPC Board and Town of Sand Lake | Pending |
| 7 | Investigate unresolved questions concerning dam ownership, property title, deed documentation, and liability. | GLPC Board; legal counsel as appropriate | Pending *Note former President and GLPC founder Peter Burkart produced a deed at the meeting. |
| 8 | Prepare a projected operating and capital budget, including anticipated engineering, maintenance, treatment, and regulatory expenses. | Carolyn Windover and finance volunteers; Will Cobb offered assistance | Pending |
| 9 | Evaluate a potential special tax district, including legal requirements, property assessments, estimated costs, and possible funding scenarios. | GLPC Board and finance/fundraising volunteers; Town consultation as needed | Exploratory; no decision made |
| 10 | Prepare and send a contribution request letter, with $250 discussed as a proposed contribution amount. | GLPC President, Treasurer, and communications volunteers | Before year-end 2026 was suggested |
| 11 | Organize door-to-door outreach to explain GLPC finances, encourage contributions, and discuss long-term funding options. | Communications and fundraising volunteers | Pending volunteer organization |
| 12 | Investigate online dues payments, automatic payments, and monthly or quarterly payment options. | Carolyn Windover and finance volunteers | Pending |
| 13 | Recruit volunteers and organize the dam, communications, finance/fundraising, and bylaws committees. | GLPC Board and membership | Ongoing |
| 14 | Develop a membership email distribution system, update contact information, and establish a process for periodic updates. | Valerie Lang Waldin, with assistance offered by Will Cobb | Pending |
| 15 | Follow up with Cyndie Mitchell, Mary Beckmann and other interested residents about communications committee participation. | Valerie Lang Waldin | Pending |
| 16 | Send a letter to the Creek Lane property owner requesting removal of the newly installed dock. | Bob Happy and GLPC, in consultation with attorney Lawrence Howard | Pending |
| 17 | Prepare for the next planned lake-lowering effort. | GLPC Board | October 2, 2027 |
| 18 | Schedule a membership vote on the revised bylaws. | GLPC Board and Secretary | Before the next meeting |
| 19 | Review Board records and notify the membership of current Board members and the beginning and ending dates of their terms. | Bob Happy and Valerie Lang Waldin | Pending |
| 20 | Review the need for additional hydraulic-flow or spillway engineering analysis and determine the appropriate next steps. | GLPC Board and engineering advisers | Pending; potential additional cost discussed |
| 21 | Clarify the status of the outstanding engineering-related bill and associated agreement addendum. | Bob Happy and Carolyn Windover | Pending |
7. Items for Continued Board Attention
The following issues should remain priorities for future meetings:
- DEC compliance and completion of required dam documentation.
- Safe reopening of the road crossing and the Town’s long-term bridge replacement plan.
- Financial stabilization and development of a sustainable funding model.
- Community outreach and increased participation in GLPC activities.
- Committee formation and recruitment of additional Board support.
- Resolution of outstanding property-title, ownership, and engineering questions.
8. Next Meeting
The next meeting date was not specified in the transcript.
9. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 11:42 AM.
***
GLPC Annual Meeting June 20, 2026 – Minutes
APPROVED at GLPC meeting October 24, 2026
Board Members Present: Bob Happy, President; Tim Komdat, Maureen Straight, Valerie Lang Waldin, Secretary; John Windover, Carolyn Windover, Treasurer
Guest Speaker: Jennifer Wesolowski, Engineer for the Glass Lake Preservation Corporation, Gomez & Sullivan Engineers
A quorum was present with 28 members.
Call to Order: Bob Happy called the meeting to order at 10:05 AM.
Update on Dam:
A debate exists between the Town of Sand Lake and the Glass Lake Preservation Corporation (GLPC) regarding the dam’s condition and the maintenance/repair responsibilities of the road and dam.
- The Town claims the dam needs repair; the GLPC engineer maintains it does not.
- The dam is 175 years old and requires strategic planning for future repairs.
- The Town is responsible for upkeep of the road.
- The GLPC engineer’s inspection reports indicate the dam is sound, with potential spillway capacity issues common in older dams.
- The dam’s stability is not negatively impacted by the current failure of the east abutment material.
- Calculations suggest the dam could lose up to 19 feet before safety is compromised.
- Town and GLPC engineer disagree on the cause of dam issues, with some attributing problems to frost thaw or road traffic.
- The dam’s condition is rated as “unsound to fair” by DEC, mainly due to storm water capacity, not structural integrity.
- The dam’s age and winter conditions pose ongoing risks, prompting discussions on long-term solutions.
Town’s Proposed Solutions and Funding Options
The town has presented multiple options for addressing the dam and road issues, with financial and legal implications.
- Three options: do nothing, create a tax district, or drain the lake.
- Draining the lake is off the table; the GLPC would take legal action if attempted.
- The Town has already allocated $30,000 for repairs; some estimates suggest total costs of $30,000 to $40,000.
- The Town claims it has $6,500 already committed for work.
- The question arose as to whether the Town has secured bids for repairs.
- The Town may front the repair costs but expects the GLPC to share expenses. This prompted concerns about setting a precedent if the GLPC pays for dam repairs.
- A long-term solution for maintenance of the dam and the future of the lake is needed.
- Detailed financials on long-term solutions are unclear but could run into millions of dollars.
- The Town is under pressure to open the road for emergency services, influencing repair priorities.
Engineering Assessments and Structural Concerns
Professional evaluations confirm the dam’s safety status and identify specific structural issues.
- Inspection reports show the dam is generally sound; however, spillway capacity may be inadequate.
- The dam’s design predates modern standards, affecting capacity and safety.
- The failure plane appears to involve gravel and soil layers, but the exact extent is unknown.
- The concrete bottom of the bridge shows deterioration; rebar is exposed.
- The dam’s rating is “unsound to fair” due to storm water passage capacity, not structural failure.
- The left abutment is stronger than the right (east), which is more vulnerable.
- The dam’s age and winter conditions increase the risk of future issues.
- Engineers recommend ongoing monitoring and strategic planning for repairs.
Legal and Political Considerations
- The dam owner or beneficiary is legally responsible for safety and maintenance.
- The Town benefits from the lake’s/dam’s public access and water management.
- The GLPC is cautious about signing agreements that waive future responsibility.
- Town officials are under political pressure to open the road and address emergency needs.
- Discussions include potential legal action if the Town drains the lake or refuses repairs.
- The Town’s assessment and valuation influence funding and legal strategies. There are no recent detailed Town engineer reports on dam or road repairs; only renderings and estimates available.
- The Town’s budget transparency issues complicate financial negotiations.
- The GLPC seeks detailed plans and costs before committing to repairs or funding.
- There is concern about setting a precedent that could impact future liability and responsibilities.
2025 Meeting Minutes:
Bob Eckert motioned to accept the 2025 meeting minutes, motioned was seconded by Jeanne Stinson. Motion carried.
Treasurer’s Report/Community Dues Collection and Participation
A discussion about dues payments, community involvement, and communication challenges ensued.
- $11,500 in 2026 dues collected so far.
- Estimated 40 dues paid out of approximately 70 homeowners.
- Many members are unaware of the importance of dues for Glass Lake community quality of life.
- Some members believe paying dues makes them liable for lawsuits, which is false.
- Suggestion to form a house-to-house outreach group to improve awareness. Cindy Mitchell offered to assist in this effort.
- Need for better communication through newsletters, website updates, and possibly online payment options like Zelle or via credit card.
- Only about 25-30 members typically attend meetings, with a decline over years.
- Proposal to increase meeting frequency and improve transparency via website updates and electronic voting.
Additional Items:
Updates on lake treatment, dam, and shoreline maintenance efforts.
- Lake treated for milfoil last year; snorkel inspections suggest treatment was effective.
- Milfoil control requires ongoing, regular maintenance, ideally every 3-5 years.
- Dike cleanup scheduled again, with participation issues among residents living on the dike.
- Dike maintenance is a DEC directive; all residents should participate.
- Town snowplowing may have impacted the road integrity.
- Potential to explore grants for dam and lake maintenance, but current status is limited by organizational tax designation (501c4 vs. 501c3).
- Charlie Braverman made a motion to change organizational status to 501c3 for better grant eligibility, which involves simple filing and has tax benefits. Cindy Mitchell seconded the motion. Motion carried.
Governance, Bylaws, and Communication Improvements
Discussion on bylaws, meeting frequency, and communication strategies.
- Bylaws are being reviewed; minor typos and outdated clauses are being identified.
- Proposed to amend bylaws for electronic voting; requires a future meeting for approval.
- Suggestion to hold biannual or quarterly meetings for better engagement and special sessions for pressing issues.
- Current communication is limited to annual meetings, parties, and website updates.
- Board members working on website enhancements, including notices, agendas, minutes, budgets, dam updates and volunteer lists.
- Minutes from meetings are posted online shortly after, with efforts to improve real-time updates.
- Emphasis on transparency, with potential plans to share membership dues payment lists upon request.
- Discussions about legal and liability issues related to property access and dog walking if uncontrolled dogs were to cause injury.
Water Quality/Science for Shoreline Residents:
Tighe’s Bistro, June 25th at 5:00 PM, speaker to begin at 5:30 PM. RSVP to Maureen Straight if interested: mstra5050@gmail.com, 518.441.4938.
Adjournment:
The meeting was adjourned at 11:17 AM.
Respectfully submitted,
Valerie Lang Waldin, Secretary
518.478.1505